[Back to Index| UCI Department of Philosophy| UCI Department of Logic and Philosophy of Science| UCI Special Collections | UCI Libraries]

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE

DEPARTMENT OF LOGIC AND PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE

COLLOQUIUM

"A Puzzle About Fear (And Suspicion, And Memory, And...)"

Abstract: "Consider the following pair of sentences:

(1a) Russell believed the proposition that mathematics reduces to logic.
(1b) Russell believed that mathematics reduces to logic. These two sentences cannot diverge in truth value: for any circumstance in which both sentences are evaluated, (1a) is true iff (1b) is.

By contrast, the following pair of sentences may well have different truth values:
(2a) Amy remembers the proposition that first order logic is undecidable.
(2b) Amy remembers that first order logic is undecidable.

Suppose that Amy took a class that covered decidability results. She may well remember what first order logic is and what it is to be decidable, and so remember the claim that first order logic is undecidable. So (2a) is true. But Amy may well have forgotten whether this claim is true or false. She recalls it being discussed, but canít remember if it or its negation was proved. Then (2b) is false.

Let us call the phenomenon illustrated by the sentence pairs substitution failure. The puzzle I wish to address is: why do we get substitution failure with sentences involving some verbs of propositional attitude but not others?"

Jeffrey C. King

Department of Philosophy

University of California, Davis

Friday, May 3, 2002

3 pm

SST 777


Jeffrey C. King

A Bibliography
Compiled by
Eddie Yeghiayan


1982

1984

1985

1987

1988

1991

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002


[Back to Index| UCI Department of Philosophy| UCI Department of Logic and Philosophy of Science| UCI Special Collections | UCI Libraries]

Copyright © All rights reserved. Regents of the University of California.